- Without a corresponding obligation, recognition does not become reparation'
While the first draft of the COP31 cover decision acknowledges developing countries' priorities on finance, trade, technology and capacity-building, "it does not yet deliver on them," a member of the Brazilian delegation told Anadolu.
Speaking on the sidelines of the UN climate summit in Antalya, the member of the Brazilian judiciary, who is attending the summit as part of the Brazilian delegation but speaking in her personal capacity, welcomed the draft's recognition of historical responsibility but said it remained largely rhetorical without binding obligations for compensation.
"Responsibility has two halves: acknowledging the duty and executing it through actual compensation. Without a corresponding obligation, recognition does not become reparation," she said.
Asked about the main sticking points among delegations, the source said negotiations had faced procedural hurdles, with some countries refusing to accept the presidency's text as a basis for talks after the process itself got off to a late start.
Where countries agree and disagree in negotiations
Following a news conference on Monday by COP31 President of Negotiations Chris Bowen on the first draft, the Brazilian delegate pointed to structural and financial bottlenecks across key negotiating tracks.
"The hardest files are the just transition mechanism (its mandate, structure and whether it will have resources of its own) and, in adaptation, the composition of the technical task force. Finance cuts across everything," she said.
On areas of convergence, the delegate said countries had found common ground on adaptation planning and sharing national experiences, noting that adaptation negotiations were further along than those on just transition.
However, disagreements persisted over methodologies, indicators and, above all, financing, she added.
What should the second draft address?
Outlining what she believes should be prioritized in the next iteration of the text, the delegate identified three key areas: establishing a Just Transition Mechanism with a clearly defined mandate and dedicated resources, safeguarding agreed language on vulnerable groups and territorial rights, and securing concrete follow-up measures for the fossil fuel transition roadmap.
She also called for greater attention to emerging pressures on energy and water resources, particularly those associated with expanding digital infrastructure.
The delegate warned against weakening existing commitments during the final stretch of negotiations, saying the main concern was not necessarily the outright removal of provisions but the risk of agreed language being stripped of its substance.
'Tripling adaptation finance covers less than a third of what is needed'
Asked whether the current draft adequately addresses the climate finance needs of developing countries, the delegate said it fell short.
She said Brazil had been calling for $1.3 trillion in annual climate finance by 2035 and for commitments to be honored in line with each country's priorities.
"By the draft's own account, tripling adaptation finance covers less than a third of what is needed," she added.
Turning to loss and damage, the source underscored the principle that major polluters should bear responsibility for the consequences of their emissions.
"A fund that depends on voluntary pledges is recognition without execution," she said.
Lessons from Brazil's COP30 presidency
Drawing on Brazil's experience hosting COP30 in Belem last year, the source said the summit demonstrated that "progress comes where the focus is implementation," citing the establishment of the Just Transition Mechanism and the adaptation finance target.
However, she said Belem also exposed "the cost of leaving the hardest issue, fossil fuels, out of the final text."
Offering advice to the Turkish presidency, the delegate urged it to remain transparent about political and procedural difficulties, manage expectations and "not let the clock decide the outcome."
'Success is leaving Antalya with more than we had after Belem'
Asked what would constitute a successful outcome at COP31, the delegate said the summit should deliver tangible progress on implementation while keeping the door open for further advances, whether through consensus or a broad majority.
"Success is leaving Antalya with more than we had after Belem," she said.
She also identified any rollback on previously agreed commitments as a red line, warning against using the rights of vulnerable groups as bargaining chips, weakening negotiated language or accepting compromises that offer nothing in return.
"The red line is backsliding: rights used as bargaining chips, hollowed-out texts, and trade-offs that give nothing in return," she said.